The NHS failings that cost Nikki Grahame her life

Tragic Big Brother star Nikki Grahame was the victim of a series of NHS care failures that led to her 'entirely avoidable' death from anorexia, those closest to the 38-year-old have claimed

Tragic Big Brother star Nikki Grahame was the sufferer of a sequence of NHS care failures that led to her ‘fully avoidable’ loss of life from anorexia, these closest to the 38-year-old have claimed.

They have additionally revealed Nikki’s ‘determined wrestle’ to get remedy over the past six months, throughout which era she was discharged from hospital twice whereas severely unwell, on one event weighing simply three and a half stone – the equal of a seven-year-old little one.

The final time she was discharged, on Thursday April 8, she weighed lower than 5 stone. Just 12 hours later, she was lifeless.

‘If she hadn’t have been discharged, I feel she’d nonetheless be with us right now,’ mentioned one good friend who has been intently concerned with her medical case over numerous years. 

‘There are questions that have to be answered. Nikki actually wished assist – she was determined to get higher, she was even consuming full meals in hospital. 

‘But she by no means fairly managed to get the constant care she wanted.’

Tragic Big Brother star Nikki Grahame was the victim of a series of NHS care failures that led to her 'entirely avoidable' death from anorexia, those closest to the 38-year-old have claimed

Tragic Big Brother star Nikki Grahame was the sufferer of a sequence of NHS care failures that led to her ‘fully avoidable’ loss of life from anorexia, these closest to the 38-year-old have claimed

Fragile fame: Nikki with her mum Susan at a party soon after her stint in the Big Brother house

Fragile fame: Nikki with her mum Susan at a celebration quickly after her stint within the Big Brother home

Experts say tales like Nikki’s are ‘not unusual sufficient’. They communicate of a ‘revolving door’ wherein sufferers are discharged, typically ‘too early’ and with out satisfactory help, solely to finish up again in hospital, far sicker than once they began.

‘We know persons are falling by the cracks,’ says Kerrie Jones, NHS consuming dysfunction psychotherapist and chief government officer of Orri – a personal day remedy centre. 

‘I see too many who go from having round the clock intensive take care of six months to just about nothing in a matter of weeks. 

‘We name them revolving door sufferers – they do not get constant remedy locally, which is essential for long-term restoration.

‘Inevitably, they find yourself spiralling and land again in hospital once more.’

Nikki, who stole the nation’s coronary heart with her effervescent and girlish allure on the 2006 sequence of Big Brother, suffered bouts of anorexia – the deadliest consuming dysfunction – from the age of 9. 

Until lately, pals say, her situation was comparatively steady. She was pursuing a brand new profession in instructing and was taking programs in English and science.

But her sickness returned throughout lockdown. In an interview final month, her mom Susan described the ‘terminal loneliness’ that consumed her daughter, who lived alone although pals talking to this newspaper mentioned it was ‘extra difficult than that’.

Student Averil Hart, 19, who died in 2012

Student Averil Hart, 19, who died in 2012

Whatever the trigger, it resulted in a relapse final summer season. Nikki was beneath the care of an NHS consuming dysfunction service in Central London, a part of the Central and North West London Foundation Trust ‘for a number of years’, based on a good friend.

Appointments with psychiatrists and dieticians supplied by the service had been ‘irregular’. Around June, Nikki started to drop pounds.

‘She’d struggled with erratic consuming habits and extreme gym-going for years, but it surely was comparatively effectively managed as a result of she knew she needed to keep effectively in an effort to maintain working within the public eye,’ says a detailed good friend.

‘But when lockdown hit and she or he spent extra time alone, it gave her a chance to deal with her disordered habits, whereas additionally hiding it from others. I’d seen this behaviour in her earlier than. It was seeded earlier than lockdown, however the isolation spurred it on.’

She was round 5½st – at 5ft 1in, severely underweight – when she was admitted to the 14-bed Vincent Square Eating Disorder Service, the place she stayed for a month. 

Patients at extraordinarily low weights are at excessive threat of organ failure, deadly infections and a situation known as refeeding syndrome – the place a sudden improve in energy causes an imbalance of fluids and salts, which might have an effect on coronary heart operate. 

This means they require fixed monitoring.

At some level round July – it is not but clear precisely when – Nikki was discharged. Friends say she was nonetheless underweight at this level.

The last time Nikki (above in 2010) was discharged, on Thursday April 8, she weighed less than five stone. Just 12 hours later, she was dead

The final time Nikki (above in 2010) was discharged, on Thursday April 8, she weighed lower than 5 stone. Just 12 hours later, she was lifeless

In a press release to this newspaper, the Central and North West London Foundation Trust mentioned their ‘door remained at all times open’, however sources near Nikki acquired few follow-up appointments. 

She rapidly deteriorated and by December her weight had as soon as once more plummeted. 

Around this time, she suffered a fall – at very low weights, sufferers typically undergo steadiness issues, lack of muscle management and sudden collapses – and acquired hospital remedy for a cracked pelvis and damaged wrist.

Severe malnutrition brought on by anorexia ends in a depletion of vitamins wanted to restore and develop wholesome bone tissue, leaving victims susceptible to the bone-thinning illness osteoporosis, and fractures and breakages. 

A good friend says Nikki noticed a number of medical doctors for check-ups on her accidents over the next two months, however her critically low weight was by no means addressed.

By February, two shut pals visited her London flat for the primary time in six months and had been shocked by her decline.

She weighed 3st 7lb. ‘We simply thought, she’s going to die,’ mentioned one. ‘She was on her personal due to lockdown and there was no method of checking up on what she was or wasn’t consuming. 

But she was calling out for assist, ringing round non-public medical doctors and native clinics to ask in the event that they’d take her in. She actually, actually wished to get higher. 

She simply did not understand how. On just a few events we known as ambulances to her flat within the hope that she’d be admitted to hospital and get into remedy that method.’

Nikki informed pals she had been discharged by Central and North West London NHS Foundation Trust, so was ‘not on the books’ and so ineligible for remedy. The Trust informed this newspaper they believed she’d ‘moved away’. 

Nikki additionally informed pals she had visited her GP to ask for another consuming dysfunction specialist clinic, however no referral was made.

It was at this level, in mid-March, that two of her closest pals began a crowdfunding charity marketing campaign in an try to boost a minimum of £25,000 for personal remedy.

Nikki, who stole the nation's heart with her effervescent and girlish charm on the 2006 series of Big Brother (above), suffered bouts of anorexia – the deadliest eating disorder – from the age of nine

Nikki, who stole the nation’s coronary heart with her effervescent and girlish allure on the 2006 sequence of Big Brother (above), suffered bouts of anorexia – the deadliest consuming dysfunction – from the age of 9

Until recently, friends say, her condition was relatively stable. She was pursuing a new career in teaching and was taking courses in English and science. Pictured: Nikki with Pete Bennett

Until lately, pals say, her situation was comparatively steady. She was pursuing a brand new profession in instructing and was taking programs in English and science. Pictured: Nikki with Pete Bennett

Many non-public clinics do not need the medical amenities to take care of severely unwell sufferers, so require them to achieve a physique mass index (BMI) rating of a minimum of 12 earlier than admission. 

BMI is a weight to top ratio utilized by medical doctors to see if sufferers are a wholesome weight. Anything beneath 18.5 is taken into account underweight. Nikki’s BMI was 9 on the time.

One non-public London clinic agreed to take her, as long as she may acquire roughly a stone and a half earlier than beginning remedy on April 12, as in any other case the medical threat was thought of too excessive.

At some level round March 15, Nikki travelled by taxi to her mom’s home, on the Dorset and Devon border. She informed a good friend she stopped at a pharmacy roughly ten miles from her mum’s the place she suffered one other critical fall, fracturing her decrease backbone.

An ambulance took her to Dorset County Hospital in Dorchester, the place A&E medical doctors carried out exams earlier than transferring her to a short-stay acute ward, often occupied by severely unwell aged sufferers.

Nikki was visibly underweight, and her medical doctors, suspecting that she was affected by an consuming dysfunction, known as psychiatrists from the native psychological well being crew to make an evaluation. 

It isn’t clear why she was not transferred to the Trust’s consuming dysfunction specialist centre – however pals counsel it might have been because of a scarcity of obtainable beds.

Then, on Thursday April 8, Nikki was discharged. It isn’t but clear why, nonetheless she informed a good friend that her weight was 5st at that time.

‘I spoke to the obligation physician the day earlier than she was discharged on the telephone and pleaded with him to not let her go away – I mentioned she’s not prepared,’ mentioned the good friend.

‘Up till that day, she wished to remain in hospital. They had been so sort, she mentioned it was higher than the care she’d acquired at any anorexia unit. But as quickly because the physician mentioned she was prepared to go away, she began to consider she was effectively sufficient to go residence and have become enthusiastic about it.

‘I requested a minimum of for extra time so we may organise somebody to be there to handle her. But the following day they let her get in a taxi on her personal and journey residence.’

Pictured: Nikki at the National Television Awards at Royal Albert Hall in 2006

Pictured: Nikki on the National Television Awards at Royal Albert Hall in 2006

Nikki arrived again in London early that night and made telephone calls to pals to inform them she’d arrived safely. That evening she died, reportedly in her sleep. A autopsy is being carried out subsequent week.

Shocking as this all could seem, it’s not the primary time such a mixture of issues have had devastating penalties.

In 2012, 19-year-old anorexia sufferer Averil Hart from Suffolk died at Addenbrooke’s Hospital, Cambridge, after collapsing in her room on campus on the University of East Anglia. 

Averil, who was first identified with the sickness aged 15, was first taken to the Norfolk and Norwich University Hospital, in a ‘severely malnourished’ state, however acquired no dietary or psychiatric help throughout her four-day admission, earlier than an pressing switch to Addenbrooke’s.

At the inquest, elements recognized as contributors to her loss of life included medical doctors who knew ‘virtually nothing’ about anorexia, ‘no follow-up’ from the native consuming dysfunction crew and failure to offer life-saving remedy, equivalent to a feeding tube, whereas beneath the care of Norfolk and Norwich University Hospital.

In December 2016, 45-year-old Amanda Bowles, from Cambridge, was discharged by the Cambridge and Peterborough NHS Foundation Trust’s consuming dysfunction service regardless of her ‘critically low’ physique mass index – and fewer than a yr later was discovered lifeless in her flat. 

An inquest heard the mother-of-one had been scuffling with extreme anorexia for over a yr however after her discharge was not monitored for six months, throughout which she ‘considerably deteriorated’ and ‘was at a excessive threat of loss of life’.

More lately, in January 2018, Edinburgh University pupil Madeline Wallace, 19, died from sepsis – a standard reason for loss of life in anorexia sufferers.

Madeline, from Peterborough, had suffered with anorexia for 2 years and skilled ‘gaps’ in her remedy. 

Having quickly declined on the finish of 2017, she started struggling signs associated to extreme malnourishment – which her GP described as ‘within the vary of regular’. 

Days later, an out-of-hours physician made an pressing referral to hospital, but it surely was rejected because of a scarcity of beds. She died two days later.

According to a 2020 coroner’s report into the difficulty, these deaths are prone to be the tip of the iceberg, because of ‘important beneath reporting’ with regards to fatalities involving the consuming problems.

Coroner Sean Hornstead mentioned that because of a lack of expertise amongst medical professionals, many sufferers had been listed as having died from ‘pure causes’, when in reality an consuming dysfunction was responsible.

Royal College of Psychiatrists steerage states anorexia sufferers with a BMI beneath 15 ought to be thought of for hospitalisation. Ideally, this ought to be in an consuming dysfunction specialist unit, the place medical doctors can carry out weekly blood exams, coronary heart scans and muscle power exams in addition to twice-weekly weigh-ins.

Facilities are suggested to make a full psychological well being evaluation of sufferers and, as a final resort, detain them beneath the Mental Health Act – sometimes called ‘being sectioned’ – and deal with them, if needed, in opposition to their will.

This is completed as a result of distressed sufferers could refuse meals, regardless of being a critically low weight, pull out feeding tubes or self-harm.

Patients must also be counselled by psychological well being help employees and dieticians, to assist them address the anxiousness they really feel after consuming. But a nationwide scarcity of beds means many find yourself in inappropriate amenities.

Andrew Radford, CEO of the UK’s eating-disorder charity Beat, mentioned Covid has worsened the state of affairs. ‘Social distancing measures means there’s even fewer specialist beds out there,’ he mentioned. 

Pictured: Nikki during an appearance on Lorraine in November 2018

Pictured: Nikki throughout an look on Lorraine in November 2018

‘Adult sufferers would possibly discover themselves in a basic hospital ward, having been admitted as a medical emergency.

‘But typically medical doctors aren’t completely certain what the correct factor to do is, or are unaware of the distinctive challenges of working with somebody within the throes of anorexia.’

Recent NHS information reveals solely roughly half of all grownup consuming dysfunction sufferers in want of hospitalisation are handled on specialist models. Roughly a tenth had been on the whole medical wards, typically these specialising in gastroenterology.

A 2017 Royal College of Psychiatrists report raised considerations about very unwell consuming dysfunction sufferers doing ‘very badly’ and ‘sometimes dying’, after being handled on non-specialist models.

The drawback was mentioned to be ‘sufficiently widespread to offer rise to critical concern.’

And then there’s the issue of what occurs when sufferers go away hospital. All too typically, they’re left unmonitored, quickly changing into desperately unwell.

After hospital discharge, Royal College of Psychiatrists’ steerage states that sufferers ought to transition to both intensive day care or community-based care, the place they obtain common appointments with dieticians, psychiatrists and psychological well being nurses for a minimum of six months – relying on their restoration.

But this gold-standard method is changing into much less and fewer widespread, say specialists.

‘The basic case we see is somebody will get out of hospital and the care virtually instantly drops off,’ says Mr Radford. ‘The drawback would not resolve, and the longer it goes on, the harder it’s to deal with them, as behaviours turn into ingrained. So they simply find yourself out and in of remedy – it is infuriating.’

Recent NHS information reveals some adults are ready greater than three years for an appointment with a neighborhood consuming dysfunction specialist, equivalent to psychiatrist or psychological well being nurse.

One 32-year-old girl informed this newspaper about how she was left for six months with out follow-up care instantly after hospital discharge, in addition to receiving no psychological help whereas in remedy.

Another informed of being discharged from hospital and informed by medical doctors, ‘you understand what it is advisable do – simply acquire weight’, regardless of being a BMI of 15 – simply above medically harmful.

So what is the resolution? More funding, for sources and specialist workers would, after all, assist.

‘Early intervention for younger folks has lengthy been the precedence [for funding] as a result of that is the place you see essentially the most success by way of restoration,’ says Professor Janet Treasure, advisor psychiatrist and one of many UK’s main consuming dysfunction specialists.

Over the previous six years, kids and adolescent consuming dysfunction providers have acquired an additional £50 million per yr.

Adults, then again, haven’t. The Government has pledged £1 billion in funding for grownup psychological well being providers this yr, however it’s not but clear precisely how a lot will probably be ring-fenced for consuming problems.

Mr Radford says: ‘They wanted an additional £50 million for youngsters and just one in six consuming dysfunction sufferers are kids.

‘So it may take a hell of numerous funding to unravel the issue.’

Many specialists say that a whole overhaul of the hospital discharge course of can also be wanted.

‘All too typically folks fall by the cracks as a result of there isn’t any one level of contact they’ll go to once they come out of hospital,’ Mr Radford says.

‘At the very least, we’re calling for a constant workers member who will investigate cross-check sufferers often, not a clinician, essentially, simply somebody who can see them and establish warning indicators.’

Prof Treasure and her analysis crew at King’s College London are trialling one revolutionary concept – coaching members of the family, group leaders and former victims to advocate on behalf of sufferers after discharge. 

‘Eating dysfunction sufferers typically do not suppose they’re worthy of assist, so will not attain out for it until they’re pushed. This method, we’re not counting on them to assist themselves,’ she says.

Nikki Grahame’s pals are additionally calling for change. When initially approached, they had been reluctant to talk publicly about her loss of life. But after some thought, they agreed.

‘If there’s one factor I do know, it is that Nikki would need us to be shouting from the rooftops about what occurred to her,’ says one good friend. 

‘All she ever wished was to cease it from taking place to others.’

A spokesman for Dorset County Hospital NHS Foundation Trust mentioned: ‘A full inside investigation into the circumstances of Miss Grahame’s loss of life is at the moment beneath method. All information and findings will probably be shared confidentially with Miss Grahame’s household.’


Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *