We independently choose these merchandise—in case you purchase from considered one of our hyperlinks, we could earn a fee.
The mayonnaise class has actually exploded. Your choices earlier than used to simply be … mayo. These days, you possibly can select between vegan mayo, natural mayo, avocado oil-based mostly mayo, and spicy mayo, all along with previous-college classics. And there are many choices for every. But mayo actually is simply an emulsion of eggs (or a vegan different), oil, and an acid (like lemon juice or vinegar). So I couldn’t assist however marvel if there actually was an enormous distinction in taste among the many many choices.
Nobody desires to spend a number of days gorging on straight mayo (myself included!), however that’s precisely what I did not too long ago, as a result of I needed to know the reality. My egg salad sandwiches trusted it. Out of the handfuls of mayonnaise varieties on the grocery store in the present day, does one stand out among the many relaxation?
I visited a spread of supermarkets and gathered each model I may discover in six fashionable classes: traditional, natural, avocado oil-based mostly, vegan, truffle, and Sriracha (as a result of having a great spicy mayo readily available is vital). From retailer manufacturers and large manufacturers to nationally accessible boutique producers, I ended up with greater than two-dozen sorts of mayo.
- How I Tested the Mayonnaise
- The Best Classic Mayonnaise: Best Foods/Hellmann’s and Duke’s Mayonnaise
- The Best Organic Mayonnaise: Trader Joe’s Organic Mayonnaise
- The Best Avocado Oil Mayonnaise: Chosen Foods Avocado Oil-Based Classic Mayo
- The Best Vegan Mayonnaise: HLTHPUNK Bionnaise Vegan Mayo
- The Best Truffle Mayonnaise: Truff
- The Best Sriracha Mayonnaise: Lee Kum Kee
How I Tested the Mayonnaise
I tasted every mayonnaise blind and by itself (yep, by the spoonful) and evaluated it based mostly on shade, texture, and taste. Mayonnaise is meant to be a creamy, balanced backdrop — a method so as to add richness and assist different flavors shine. I used to be searching for the mayo that was creamy however not greasy, mushy however not skinny or drippy, pleasantly pale in shade however not beige, and tart however not an excessive amount of so.
Then I tasted every mayo on a chunk of bread with a skinny slice of ham — no different condiments — to see how effectively it carried out on a sandwich. Was it too sharp? Too candy? Was it so bland it simply tasted like grease? Did it soak into the bread like a sauce or sit on high like a creamy cushion?
For the ultimate take a look at of those mayos, I made a tiny batch of egg salad with each — only a single chopped-up arduous-boiled egg and a scant little bit of mayo. I used to be seeking to see how effectively the mayo complemented the richness of the egg with out stomping throughout it.
The spicy mayos have been dealt with in another way. After tasting them solo, evaluating for consistency, taste, and warmth stage (with numerous sips of milk in between), I then dipped Vietnamese pork meatballs into them to see how effectively they’d work in one thing that sometimes requires Sriracha mayo, like a meatball banh mi.
While the entire mayonnaises labored effectively — I can’t say a single one made a nasty sandwich or egg salad — I in a short time zeroed in on a couple of favorites.
The Best Classic Mayonnaise: Best Foods/Hellmann’s and Duke’s Mayonnaise
A tie! This was a tricky class to guage as a result of all of the mayos have been fairly darn good and I may see utilizing a few of them in particular purposes. For instance, the Kewpie mayo was delightfully tart and tremendous mushy and saucy. It’s too skinny for a sandwich and made my egg salad too citrusy, but it surely was nonetheless scrumptious. It could be nice drizzled on one thing fried and wealthy. Many of the opposite mayos have been only a bit too candy or too tart or too agency or too mushy or too bland to encourage us to succeed in for them once more. Two, nevertheless, have been deemed good. The first was Best Foods (aka Hellman’s, if you’re east of the Rockies), which was a right away fave. It’s very wealthy and eggy in taste and maybe probably the most harmonious mayo ever created, with salt and acid in good steadiness and a wealthy easy texture that’s under no circumstances greasy.
Buy: Best Foods Mayonnaise, $3.89 for 30 ounces at Target
My group of testers and I stored coming again to this different mayo that was so silky and decadent with an virtually tacky umami word. It was flat-out scrumptious by itself, and made the ham sandwich into one thing particular. That one turned out to be Duke’s, a Southern favourite that’s not tremendous frequent in my neck of the woods. Luckily, you possibly can order it online wherever you reside.
Buy: Duke’s Mayonnaise, $3.59 for 32 ounces
The Best Organic Mayonnaise: Trader Joe’s Organic Mayonnaise
Good ol’ Trader Joe’s simply nabbed first place, beating out opponents that value double or virtually triple the value. Most natural mayos have been very related in taste to the classics however barely extra tart. What I preferred about TJ’s was how creamy and wealthy it was whereas being completely balanced in tartness. It was vibrant and acidic and made for a harmonious egg salad, and virtually-decadent ham sandwich.
More data: Trader Joe’s Organic Mayonnaise, $3.69 for 16 ounces in shops
The Best Avocado Oil Mayonnaise: Chosen Foods Avocado Oil-Based Classic Mayo
This class was a shocker. I couldn’t consider how tremendous-seasoned and tremendous-citrusy these choices tasted in comparison with the classics. Why would utilizing avocado oil as a substitute of the standard canola or vegetable oil require such heavy-handed flavorings? Chosen Foods was the most effective of the bunch. This avocado mayo tasted probably the most balanced and performed effectively in different purposes, with a stunning, silky texture — not too stiff and never too saucy.
Buy: Chosen Foods Avocado Oil-Based Classic Mayo, $8.49 for 12 ounces
The Best Vegan Mayonnaise: HLTHPUNK Bionnaise Vegan Mayo
HLTHPUNK’s Bionnaise is created from a sunflower oil and oat-milk based mostly recipe, which makes this plant-based mostly mayo an ideal possibility for anybody with an aversion to soy (which is normally the choice within the vegan mayo class). HLTHPUNK’s Bionnaise actually shines in a sandwich software. It is available in a helpful squeezable tube and is flavorful, due to additions like turmeric and white pepper.
Buy: HLTHPUNK Bionnaise Vegan Mayo, $9.99 for 4.8 ounces at Walmart
The Best Truffle Mayonnaise: Truff
If you like truffles, that is the mayo for you. Some different ones on the market may be too over-powering within the truffle division (sure, that’s a factor) or too gluey. Made with natural eggs, sunflower oil, and black winter truffles, these items has the precise taste steadiness and the smoothest consistency. You’ll need to apply it to sandwiches, burgers, and whilst a dipping sauce for fries.
Buy: Truff Mayo, $24.99 for 2 8-ounce jars at Truff
The Best Sriracha Mayonnaise: Lee Kum Kee
To win this class, the mayo needed to not simply be spicy, but it surely additionally needed to style like precise Sriracha. That’s why Lee Kum Kee’s Sriracha mayo got here out on high. It provided a large amount of warmth that wasn’t overpowering, and actually tasted like Sriracha blended with mayo.
Buy: Lee Kum Kee Sriracha Mayonnaise, $3.98 for 15 ounces at Walmart