Commentary: Jack Ma brought the wrath of Chinese regulators down on Alibaba

HONG KONG: Ever since Alibaba founder Jack Ma criticised Chinese monetary regulation in a speech final October, a regulatory storm has pummelled the nation’s complete online monetary and shopper sector.

The Shanghai Stock Exchange suspended the deliberate preliminary public providing of fintech conglomerate Ant Group – an Alibaba affiliate – simply two days earlier than its launch, and regulators subsequently launched an enormous crackdown on Chinese Big Tech.

While Ma’s speech seems to have been an unforeseeable random occasion, the logic of Chinese bureaucratic politics made Ant’s IPO debacle inevitable.


Power inside the Chinese paperwork is fragmented amongst central ministries and ranges of authorities. A division’s mission and targets decide its stance and method towards regulating companies.

China beforehand regulated its monetary system utilizing a “one bank and three commissions” construction.

The People’s Bank of China (PBOC), the central financial institution, was accountable for financial coverage and macro-prudential regulation, whereas separate banking and insurance coverage regulators and the China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC) oversaw their respective sectors.

READ: Commentary: Why a bumper crop of Southeast Asian tech unicorns look set to IPO this year

But these establishments’ overlapping capabilities and lack of coordination allowed some non-financial corporations to hunt regulatory arbitrage, as the fallout from monetary scandals involving the Anbang Insurance Group and Tomorrow Group made clear. 

After these scandals got here to gentle, the Chinese authorities carried out a collection of organisational shakeups to handle regulatory failures.

In 2017, the nineteenth National Congress of the Communist Party of China made decreasing monetary threat a high financial precedence, and emphasised “high-quality” somewhat than “high-speed” development. 

The State Council additionally established the Financial Stability and Development Committee, a super-regulator headed by Vice Premier Liu He, to train complete oversight, significantly over monetary actions that fall by the cracks of conventional regulation.

Man wearing a mask walks past the headquarters of the People's Bank of China, the central bank

A person sporting a masks walks previous the headquarters of the People’s Bank of China, the central financial institution, in Beijing, China, as the nation is hit by an outbreak of the new coronavirus, February 3, 2020. REUTERS/Jason Lee/Files

An enormous authorities overhaul in 2018 additional consolidated monetary regulatory energy by merging the banking and insurance coverage regulators into the China Banking and Insurance Regulatory Commission (CBIRC). 

Meanwhile, the PBOC took over the CBIRC’s legislative capabilities, additional solidifying the central financial institution’s main function in sustaining monetary stability. 

In addition, CBIRC Chairman Guo Shuqing was additionally appointed celebration secretary of the PBOC, a transfer broadly seen as a step towards facilitating coordination between the two banking regulators. 

READ: Commentary: Maybe Jack Ma became too powerful for China’s liking

By 2018, due to this fact, the stability was already tilting towards tighter regulation of non-financial companies. 


Ant is one of these targets. From the begin, the group has marketed itself as an web expertise agency that makes use of Alipay, its extremely in style mobile-payment app, to offer a variety of monetary companies. 

But Ant presents Chinese regulators with unprecedented challenges as a result of many of its companies fall exterior the scope of present monetary guidelines. 

Moreover, Ant’s exponential development and aggressive enlargement into new enterprise traces have put regulators on excessive alert. 

One of the PBOC’s most necessary financial coverage instruments is adjusting banks’ capital reserve necessities, however Ant didn’t must fulfill these necessities, as a result of it’s not a financial institution. 

Regulators grew to become much more alarmed when Ant’s IPO submitting revealed additional particulars about the scale and threat mannequin of its lending enterprise. 

The extremely oversubscribed providing, and the large valuation premium Ant obtained by being a tech agency somewhat than a financial institution, stoked fears of a bubble. 

Yi Gang, President of the People's Bank of China, has said China's own digital currency

Yi Gang, President of the People’s Bank of China, has stated China’s personal digital forex could be related to digital cost techniques, equivalent to the in style WeChat and AliPay cellphone apps AFP/WANG Zhao

Although the default price on Ant’s loans is comparatively low, the group’s brief historical past – six years – and huge dimension pose potential unexpected perils – which, from the PBOC’s standpoint, might quantity to systemic threat. 

As the lender of final resort, the central financial institution is of course threat averse; if Ant fails, the financial institution must bail it out.

READ: Commentary: Politicians are using yesterday’s tools for today’s tech challenges

Other Chinese monetary regulators could have a totally totally different threat profile. 

The CSRC reportedly authorized Ant’s IPO software inside simply two months, in comparison with the typical seven months or extra for different listings, as a way to increase confidence in China’s inventory market amid deteriorating relations with the United States. 


Ant’s deliberate twin itemizing in Shanghai and Hong Kong was supposed not solely to entice extra Chinese tech corporations to record domestically, but in addition to counter US threats to delist Chinese corporations from its inventory exchanges.

But the PBOC has different priorities. Its mission to make sure monetary stability makes it a persistent regulator, and Ma’s speech gave the central financial institution precisely the opening it wanted to rein in Ant. 

His scathing criticisms of Chinese monetary regulation straight irked many senior officers who beforehand had voiced contrasting opinions on the identical regulatory points. 

These policymakers quickly revealed their displeasure with Ma and Ant. A couple of days after the speech, the PBOC-affiliated newspaper Financial News revealed three consecutive commentaries criticizing Ant’s enterprise mannequin.

FILE PHOTO: A thermal imaging camera is seen in front of a logo of Ant Group at the headquarters of

A thermal imaging digital camera is seen in entrance of a emblem of Ant Group at the headquarters of Ant Group, an affiliate of Alibaba, in Hangzhou, Zhejiang province, China, Oct 29, 2020. (Photo: REUTERS/Aly Song)

Once the highly effective central financial institution publicly turned in opposition to Ant, bureaucrats who had endorsed the group fell silent and different departments started to leap on the bandwagon. 

For instance, China’s antitrust authority has all the time had a transparent curiosity in regulating the nation’s massive tech corporations as a way to increase its coverage area, however had been taking a lax method as a result of it was unsure whether or not to place innovation or regulation first.

READ: Commentary: Why did China wait so long to crack down on Alibaba?

READ: Commentary: How Tencent, that other Chinese Big Tech giant, is beating a path to a trillion dollars

The high management’s opposed response to Ma’s speech gave the authority the inexperienced gentle to behave in opposition to tech giants like Alibaba. 

Ant’s fast development and emergence as an web finance titan mirrored not solely regulatory lag but in addition the agency’s agile adaptation to rule modifications. 

“We always step ahead of the regulators – we have to,” Ma stated in 2017. “Otherwise, we go nowhere.”

This time, although, it appears the regulators have lastly caught up.

Angela Huyue Zhang is Director of The Center for Chinese Law and Associate Professor at the University of Hong Kong. She is the writer of Chinese Antitrust Exceptionalism: How the Rise of China Challenges Global Regulation.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button