Commentary: India had managed to curb COVID-19. That has now changed

SINGAPORE: In February, COVID-19 was in retreat in India. Infections dropped precipitously from 100,000 instances per day in September 2020 to as little as 8,635 on Feb 1. 

From Dec 29 to Mar 12 – for greater than 10 weeks – India maintained a weekly common of about 20,000 instances, prompting some to recommend the nation had hit herd immunity. 

Unfortunately, since Mar 10, every day instances have been on the rise surpassing the 20,000 degree, hitting greater than 68,000 on Monday (Mar 29) – a five-month excessive for India. The weekly common now stands at greater than 53,000.   

READ: Commentary: COVID-19 will cast long shadows of social repercussions

The drop in instances initially – given India’s dimension, density, issue to bodily distance, at the very least in city areas, and patchy insurance policies – has mystified scientists, students, and public well being specialists alike. 

Especially when the federal government had eased restrictions and reopened the financial system throughout this era. 

Why did instances drop and why have they since risen? 

We don’t have a definitive reply to the puzzle. Rather, a number of components might have contributed to the dip, which resulted in file low instances and the rise we’re seeing now. 


India has sure benefits that seem to have labored in its favour with COVID-19 instances and fatalities. 

For one, demographics have been a boon. Only 6.18 per cent of the Indian inhabitants is over 65, which helped scale back mortality charges. 

India now information round 240 deaths per day from COVID-19 however for a lot of February, this quantity had dropped under 100. 

Spread of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) in New Delhi

Relatives mourn the demise of a person due to the coronavirus illness (COVID-19), at a crematorium in New Delhi, India September 28, 2020. REUTERS/Adnan Abidi

Even now, India’s pandemic-caused deaths – at 0.19 per 1 million of the inhabitants – is decrease than the US (2.90) and UK (0.95).  

For occasion, in Italy and Japan the place 22.7 p.c and 28 per cent, respectively, of the inhabitants are within the above 65 cohort, the fatality fee is larger. 

On per 1 million of the inhabitants, Japan’s COVID-19 demise fee is 0.25 whereas Italy’s is 7.07.

Second, India’s geographic make-up might have blunted COVID-19’s efficiency. 

Nearly 70 per cent of the inhabitants survives on agriculture, dwelling in rural areas, which impacts transmission patterns, presumably giving authorities time to arrest outbreaks earlier than they unfold. 

The group most devastated by the pandemic is presumably the city poor, who lack the means and mechanisms to cope with capricious lockdowns, onerous journey restrictions, and different constraints. 

READ: Commentary: Without a vaccine, how can pregnant mothers protect themselves against COVID-19?

READ: Commentary: US at inflection point in beating COVID-19

India’s inside migrants have suffered from the preliminary lockdown in March 2020, which gave them 4 hours of discover, after which they discovered themselves and not using a job, shelter or social help. 

Mass migration ensued in the direction of the countryside – tens of hundreds of thousands left India’s cities in April and May 2020 – throughout which many confronted extreme, usually deadly, destitution.

Other public well being measures might have made a distinction in reducing infections. 

First, testing and identification, the primary strains of defence, improved. India scaled up its laboratory capability as circumstances on the bottom changed. 

Early on, Indian officers extensively relied on the PCR take a look at, the gold commonplace of testing, earlier than switching to fast antigen assessments (RAT), that are much less dependable however yield outcomes faster. 

Infectious illness specialists typically agree that nations ought to use each strategies, mixing the much less delicate RAT with the extra correct PCR. The Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) and the Ministry of Health (MOHFW) have additionally enhanced testing effectivity by growing provides like swabs for home use. 

Better private and non-private testing additionally decreased the time in getting take a look at outcomes again, which affected isolation and quarantine methods. 

Contact tracing and concomitant isolation measures allowed the federal government to perceive how infections’ unfold and handle it thereafter. 

Rapid antigen testing campaign for coronavirus disease (COVID-19), in Ahmedabad

A person reacts as a healthcare employee collects a swab pattern from him for a fast antigen take a look at throughout a testing marketing campaign for coronavirus illness (COVID-19), at a kiosk in Ahmedabad, India, March 22, 2021. REUTERS/Amit Dave

New Delhi additionally labored with the non-public sector to design and mandate a contact tracing app, Aarogya Setu, which makes use of GPS and Bluetooth indicators to alert customers of COVID-19 instances round them. 

The Indian public additionally responded to fight the pandemic. Mask use elevated. Indian well being officers declare that India’s success comes down to unquestioned masks acceptance and use. 

Authorities from the prime minister down urged residents to use masks, in contrast to different nations the place the problem entangled with questions of freedom and autonomy. 

READ: Commentary: With millions vaccinated, Israel is test case for life after COVID-19

Police officers in cities like Delhi issued penalties to implement masks use. 

Rising masks demand was met by native producers, which doubled their manufacturing capability to practically 4 billion. 

Production reached a stage in late 2020 the place the federal government might raise a ban on the export of N-95 masks to assist producers clear extra stock and resume manufacturing. 


Given these measures, how can we clarify the current spike in infections? 

Cases are rising throughout the nation with Maharashtra main the best way. Some of the measures indicated above might have flagged, particularly masks use and testing as complacency among the many public and officers on the bottom crept in. 

Election campaigns, particularly in populous states like Tamil Nadu and West Bengal, might have triggered the uptick. 

India State Election

Indeed, infections are rising in each states. Furthermore, months-long, giant scale protests by farmers on the outskirts of Delhi and throughout Punjab and Haryana might have additionally contributed to rising infections. 

Finally, given India’s dimension, it’s attainable new COVID-19 variants might have accelerated the current unfold, although proof right here seems inconclusive. 

It is probably going that complacency and a way of optimism round potential herd immunity in sure areas might have unleashed the present surge. 

Recent serological assessments point out that this might be the case. 

READ: Commentary: Is Southeast Asia on track for post-pandemic recovery?

In main cities, particularly in slums, populations with COVID-19 antibodies have been estimated to be between 20 per cent and 50 per cent in August to September final yr, which suggests some type of immunity. 

In a current research protecting rural and concrete Karnataka, with a inhabitants of about 64 million, researchers estimated that the an infection fee was 47 per cent. 

While it’s unclear what quantity of the inhabitants wants to be contaminated to purchase herd immunity, some researchers suppose it might be under 50 per cent. 

Decreasing case hundreds and public pronouncements of herd immunity might have lulled Indian residents into believing that the worst has handed. Mask use seems to have waned. 

Masks were made compulsory in many Indian states

Masks have been made obligatory in lots of Indian states. (File photograph: AFP/Arun Sankar)

Herd immunity or not, New Delhi should increase testing processes, establish instances, implement masks orders, and different related distancing measures whereas making certain sufficient information flows up to monitor the transmission of the virus. 

Monitoring the unfold of recent variants – that some scientists declare is behind the current surge in instances – needs to be made a precedence by enhancing ongoing genome sequencing efforts. 

READ: Commentary: What’s behind India’s generous vaccine diplomacy?

READ: Commentary: Chinese vaccine diplomacy in Southeast Asia seeds goodwill but has limited strategic gains

The arrival and administration of vaccines might have additionally, paradoxically, spiked instances. Vaccines breed complacency. 

India has an vital benefit over different growing nations: A large proportion of the world’s vaccines are manufactured inside its borders. 

Vaccines are now accessible comparatively shortly in massive cities, the place infections are choosing up. New Delhi has to redouble vaccination efforts throughout city and rural areas. 

More than 40 million Indian residents have obtained, at the very least, one dose of a coronavirus vaccine. This tempo should quicken to blunt the resurgence. 

The authorities hopefully didn’t make a deadly mistake when it authorised the regionally produced Covaxin earlier than the outcomes of phase-3 trials have been accessible. 

People queue to register their names to get a dose of COVISHIELD, a coronavirus disease (COVID-19)

People queue to register their names to get a dose of COVISHIELD, a coronavirus illness (COVID-19) vaccine manufactured by Serum Institute of India, at an auditorium, which has been transformed into a short lived vaccination centre, in Ahmedabad, India, March 26, 2021. REUTERS/Amit Dave

This blindspot might have dented public belief in Delhi’s vaccination’s marketing campaign, together with amongst medical personnel. Fortunately, Covaxin turned out to be protected and efficient and India now has a number of vaccines authorised. 

The success or failure of India’s pandemic response in 2021 shall be measured by whether or not the Indian authorities can rekindle the successes wrought by numerous insurance policies close to the top of 2020 and the way efficient the continued vaccination marketing campaign is. 

Dr Karthik Nachiappan is Research Fellow on the Institute of South Asian Studies on the National University of Singapore. He is the writer of Does India Negotiate? revealed by Oxford University Press in October 2019. Dr Diego Maiorano is a Visiting Research Fellow on the Institute of South Asian Studies (ISAS) on the National University of Singapore.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button