NEW DELHI: Recent conciliatory strikes by India’s nationalist authorities on its western flank have rightly aroused international curiosity.
But Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s calculus seems comparatively easy. Faced with continued Chinese aggression on India’s northern frontier and a probably Taliban resurgence in Afghanistan, enhancing relations on the nation’s western flank, with Pakistan, appears prudent.
In latest weeks, there have been reviews of secret back-channel talks between Indian and Pakistani safety officers – facilitated by the United Arab Emirates – aimed toward easing bilateral tensions.
- READ: India’s Modi discusses Kashmir elections in first talks since autonomy revoked
- READ: Commentary: The US’ hasty exit from Afghanistan is a gift to the Taliban
- READ: Commentary: The shock and awe of India’s move on Kashmir
- READ: Commentary: India has a hidden COVID-19 crisis of food
- READ: Commentary: US withdrawal from Afghanistan is hollow victory for Pakistan
- READ: India vs Pakistan: A history of conflict over Kashmir
A February 2021 ceasefire alongside the Line of Control separating Indian and Pakistani forces in the disputed Kashmir area has thus far held, allowing an environment of close to normalcy in the world.
India has additionally been speaking to the Taliban, which it lengthy derided as surrogates for the Pakistani military, reflecting the growing probability that the mullahs will reclaim energy in Kabul following the withdrawal of US forces from Afghanistan in September.
Furthermore, India has saved two of its consulates in Afghanistan closed since final 12 months, a long-standing Pakistani demand that it had resisted for 20 years.
And in late June, Modi’s authorities held surprisingly amicable talks in New Delhi with 14 mainstream Kashmiri political leaders. Almost all of them had been arrested throughout the federal government’s crackdown in the state of Jammu and Kashmir that started in August 2019, and had been demonised by the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party since then.
INDIA CAN’T AFFORD ESCALATING TENSIONS
All of this factors to a coverage shift by a authorities aware of the pressures on India’s northern frontier. Chinese troops have failed to disengage for the reason that spring of 2020, once they superior throughout disputed territory in the Ladakh area and later provoked a navy encounter that took the lives of 20 Indian troopers.
With China doggedly refusing to withdraw, regardless of 11 rounds of talks, India’s insistence on restoring the established order ante appears more and more forlorn. Hostility with China is probably to endure, in which case India can not afford escalating tensions to its west.
Indian-Pakistani relations are at their lowest degree in latest instances, owing to a collection of incidents, starting with the terrorist assault on Mumbai in November 2008 and culminating in the 2019 Indian air strike on Balakot in Pakistan.
And the Indian authorities outraged Pakistan with its August 2019 choice to strip Jammu and Kashmir of its constitutionally assured autonomy and scale back its standing to a “union territory”, straight administered from Delhi.
The Pakistani authorities subsequently mounted a worldwide marketing campaign, working particularly with Islamic nations but in addition on the United Nations, to censure India and drive it to rescind the move.
Modi had remained implacable till just lately, so the three-and-a-half-hour assembly with Kashmiri leaders was a shock improvement. The leaders, who included 4 former chief ministers of Jammu and Kashmir, spanned the spectrum of the area’s primary political events.
The Modi authorities had beforehand denounced a few of them as corrupt dynasts, accusing them of milking the state for their very own profit.
But now they had been welcomed with candy phrases and deferential protocol by Modi, Home Minister Amit Shah (India’s second strongest politician) and different senior officers.
The authorities’s crackdown in Jammu and Kashmir has not achieved any of its proclaimed targets – specifically, to inaugurate a new period of peace and improvement, eradicate terrorism, break the political grip of a few households and hasten the area’s integration with the remainder of the nation.
But it could be incorrect to see the federal government’s latest talks with the Kashmiri leaders as an admission of defeat.
INDIAN-PAKISTAN TALKS HAVE SHIFTED GOALPOSTS
The discussions centered on three points. One was an settlement to perform, with the Kashmiri events’ cooperation, a new demarcation of the state’s political constituencies, which can probably improve the Jammu area’s illustration in the state meeting.
The different agenda gadgets had been elections throughout Jammu and Kashmir, and restoration of its statehood.
Rather than a defeat for the Indian authorities, due to this fact, the talks appear to have shifted the goalposts. The earth-shattering information in August 2019 was the abolition of Article 370 of India’s structure, which assured Jammu and Kashmir’s particular autonomous standing.
But that matter was not even mentioned, as a result of it was deemed to be sub judice (petitions on the matter are pending earlier than the Supreme Court). Instead, the principle subject was restoration of statehood, which the federal government had in any case promised “at an appropriate time”.
This could lead on to a politically viable trade-off, whereby the central authorities provides Jammu and Kashmir statehood if state leaders agree to go quiet on Article 370 and depart the matter to the judiciary.
If that occurs, as appears probably, Kashmiris may have the phantasm of wresting a concession whereas the Modi authorities’s actual victory – the revocation of autonomy two years in the past – goes unchallenged by the Kashmiri events.
VICTOR STILL UNCLEAR
Meanwhile, Pakistan’s international marketing campaign in opposition to India to restore the state’s autonomy has gone nowhere.
Pakistan’s leaders have their very own causes for wanting to resume dialogue with India, however they wanted to see some motion from Modi’s authorities to justify it. Talks with Kashmiri leaders main to one thing just like the restoration of statehood could represent sufficient progress to warrant additional discussions.
The Indian authorities will thus chalk up one other win if it enters new bilateral talks with out making any actual concession on the preconditions that Pakistan has been loudly declaiming for 2 years.
These latest developments are early strikes in a slowly unfolding regional chess game. The state of affairs in Afghanistan, the implications of China’s shut financial ties with Pakistan by the Belt and Road Initiative, and the evolution of the insurgencies led by each the Afghan Taliban and its Pakistani equal, have but to play themselves out.
Simmering Kashmiri militancy might boil over, whereas Pakistan – if it is unable or unwilling to stem terror assaults from its territory on Indian targets – might once more show duplicitous in its peace overtures.
There are too many unknowns for any facet to have victory in sight. But for now, at the least, India seems to be making the appropriate strikes.
Shashi Tharoor, a former UN under-secretary-general and former Indian Minister of State for External Affairs and Minister of State for Human Resource Development, is an MP for the Indian National Congress.