The 2021 Oscar nominees, introduced March 15, featured two ladies nominated for Best Director for the primary time in Academy Award historical past. Netflix‘s hit Mank nabbed a number one 10 nominations together with Best Picture; six nominations apiece went to The Father, Judas and the Black Messiah, Minari, Nomadland, Sound of Metal and The Trial of the Chicago 7.
Regardless of which films or people win a prestigious Academy Award, disagreements are certain to come up amongst observing critics and viewers of the annual televised Oscars ceremony. Art is inherently subjective and cinema is not any exception. But with movies being a extremely in style and profitable artwork kind, public scrutiny over main awards is intensified. With the 93rd Academy Awards approaching on April 25, 2021, Stacker revisits a few of the most controversial Oscar wins within the historical past of those award ceremonies.
The commonest supply of controversy over Oscar winners is that viewers imagine there have been higher contenders that yr. While the Oscars may be criticized as predictable by viewers, some award winners pulled upsets that put the voting course of by the Academy into doubt. Awards season campaigning has been prevalent in latest a long time, main the cynical to imagine that the Oscars are given out on account of producers shaking palms with voters behind the scenes somewhat than goal high quality.
Other occasions, private elements might weigh in on observers’ unease with Oscar wins. These elements might embody tumultuous manufacturing drama, misdeeds by actors or filmmakers, or controversial public statements. These Oscar wins have spurred on discussions of separating the artist and the artwork and debates over how Oscar winners are chosen. Issues of range, sexual conduct, and filmmaking requirements are among the many most mentioned factors.
Sometimes, an Oscar win is probably not seen as controversial at its time however may very well be seen as questionable on reflection. Some movies are inclined to age much less properly with audiences as a consequence of altering social norms within the current day in comparison with totally different cultural requirements previously. In different instances, the wrongdoings of people concerned in these movies have since been unearthed or have resurfaced after such a win.
Keep studying to study extra about a few of the most extremely criticized Oscar wins, and the way they’ve aged.
You might also like: VMAs: Most popular music videos in 2019
- 2019: ‘Bohemian Rhapsody’ wins Best Editing
- 2013: Ang Lee wins Best Director for ‘Life of Pi’
- 1986: ‘Out of Africa’ wins Best Picture
- 1978: ‘Annie Hall’ wins Best Picture over ‘Star Wars’
- 1971: George C. Scott declines Best Actor for ‘Patton’
- 2017: ‘Moonlight’ wins Best Picture after presenter flub
- 2019: ‘Green Book’ wins Best Picture
- 1940: Hattie McDaniel wins Best Supporting Actress for ‘Gone With the Wind’
- 1990: ‘Driving Miss Daisy’ wins Best Picture
- 1973: Marlon Brando declines Best Actor for ‘The Godfather’
- 1995: ‘Forrest Gump’ wins Best Picture over ‘Pulp Fiction’
- 2003: Roman Polanski wins Best Director for ‘The Pianist’
- 2017: Casey Affleck wins Best Actor for ‘Manchester by the Sea’
- 1999: ‘Shakespeare in Love’ wins Best Picture over ‘Saving Private Ryan’
- 2005: ‘Crash’ wins Best Picture over ‘Brokeback Mountain’
2019: ‘Bohemian Rhapsody’ wins Best Editing
The Freddie Mercury and Queen biopic Bohemian Rhapsody was already coming into the Oscars with a number of controversies, together with the firing of director Bryan Singer after he was accused of sexual assault and the movie’s perceived lack of consideration to Mercury’s sexuality and the bigger AIDS disaster. Upon the discharge of the ultimate movie, one explicit scene with the members of Queen talking to their supervisor went viral for a excessive variety of erratic cuts. The movie’s nomination for Best Editing sparked mockery, which elevated when the movie went on to win; even the movie’s editor John Ottman doesn’t believe that the film is his best work.[Pictured: John Ottman, winner of Best Film Editing for Bohemian Rhapsody.]
2013: Ang Lee wins Best Director for ‘Life of Pi’
Critics and pundits predicted Ben Affleck can be honored with a Best Director nomination for his well-received work in Argo. However, the actor-director was surprisingly absent from the record of nominations. Instead, the winner of that yr’s trophy was Ang Lee, who had gained the identical award for Brokeback Mountain, this time profitable for Life of Pi. The surrealist survival movie had already triggered a stir for the chapter of the movie’s visible results studio Rhythm & Hues, and this was seen as a symptom of a big downside throughout the results trade. Adding insult to harm to the film’s visible results artists was the lack of gratitude for the company in Lee’s speech for his Best Director award.
1986: ‘Out of Africa’ wins Best Picture
With a director with the pedigree of Sydney Pollack and stars like Meryl Streep and Robert Redford, Out of Africa seemingly had all the correct substances for an Oscar-worthy image. But upon launch, the romantic drama movie ended up with extra of a lukewarm reception as a consequence of an extended operating time and for Redford’s efficiency. Even in the present day, critics are baffled by how Out of Africa took the top spot that evening, particularly over Steven Spielberg’s adaptation of The Color Purple.
You might also like: 100 Best Dramas of All Time
1978: ‘Annie Hall’ wins Best Picture over ‘Star Wars’
The area opera movie Star Wars (retroactively renamed as Star Wars: Episode IV—A New Hope) by George Lucas got here into the Academy Awards with a whole lot of momentum. Star Wars gained a number of technical Academy Awards, however what many imagine is without doubt one of the most influential movies of all time misplaced to Woody Allen’s Annie Hall. While the traditional movie continues to be extremely regarded, up to date filmmakers like James Cameron have argued that the win helps the notion that the Academy doesn’t like style footage. The previous few years have additionally referred to as consideration to sexual misconduct within the movie trade, with outdated allegations in opposition to Woody Allen introduced up but once more when discussing any of his work.
1971: George C. Scott declines Best Actor for ‘Patton’
In an unprecedented transfer, actor George C. Scott declined an award for Best Actor for his work as George S. Patton within the movie Patton. While Scott’s work within the movie was extremely praised, together with his opening monologue occurring to be a memorable and iconic scene, Scott disliked the awards course of, already warning the Academy months upfront to not nominate him. Despite this, Scott—who didn’t show up at the ceremony—was nominated and gained.
2017: ‘Moonlight’ wins Best Picture after presenter flub
The win for Barry Jenkins’ coming-of-age drama Moonlight wasn’t notably controversial, however somewhat how the win throughout the televised ceremony got here to be. Initially, presenters Faye Dunaway and Warren Beatty by accident introduced the winner of Best Picture to be the musical movie La La Land. However, that was the result of a mixup by accounting agency PricewaterhouseCoopers, who was accountable for tallying up the votes and handing envelopes to presenters. La La Land producer Jordan Horowitz introduced the actual consequence to the confused viewers. The musical movie had been beforehand predicted to be the winner however was criticized for its supposed “whitewashing” of American jazz.
2019: ‘Green Book’ wins Best Picture
The Viggo Mortensen and Mahershala Ali-starring film Green Book, based mostly on a real story, had already acquired in depth criticism earlier than the Oscars rolled round. The household of Ali’s character, jazz pianist Don Shirley, condemned the movie, which was produced by Nick Vallelonga, the real-life son of Mortensen’s character Frank Vallelonga. Director Peter Farrelly, who was accused of sexually inappropriate pranks whereas making earlier movies, was additionally criticized for what viewers interpreted as a “white savior” narrative. Immediately after the movie’s win, BlackKklansman director Spike Lee attempted to storm out of the ceremony in outrage.
1940: Hattie McDaniel wins Best Supporting Actress for ‘Gone With the Wind’
Actress Hattie McDaniel made movie historical past by turning into the primary black American to win an Academy Award, profitable for her position as “Mammy” in Gone With the Wind. While the award was an honor, McDaniel needed to face racism and segregation. McDaniel was solely allowed into the ceremony upon the intervention of the movie’s producers. Even then, McDaniel was seated away from the remainder of the inventive group at a segregated desk, making this historic win additionally an instance in the present day of the ugly racial historical past of the nation.
1990: ‘Driving Miss Daisy’ wins Best Picture
Unusual for the Best Picture class, 1990 winner Driving Miss Daisy didn’t even obtain a nomination for Best Director, making the win an odd one out, particularly in opposition to competitors that included Dead Poets Society, Field of Dreams, and My Left Foot. Today, the movie’s depiction of race relations is taken into account to be lowkey, protected, and spinoff, with retrospectives questioning why Spike Lee’s highly charged Do the Right Thing from the identical yr was not even nominated for Best Picture within the first place. Driving Miss Daisy has been likened many occasions over to the newer but additionally controversial Green Book.
1973: Marlon Brando declines Best Actor for ‘The Godfather’
Famed actor Marlon Brando had beforehand gained the Academy Award for Best Actor for his efficiency in On the Waterfront, however took a special strategy together with his win for The Godfather within the wake of the Wounded Knee incident. Instead of accepting the award for his position as Vito Corleone in-person, Brando despatched Apache actress and activist Sacheen Littlefeather, who gave a speech in Brando’s place to announce his intention to say no the award for “poor treatment of Native Americans in the film industry.” Littlefeather acquired a mixture of cheers and boos from the viewers. However, the incident continues to be appeared again upon as a big second in recognizing indigenous rights within the United States.
You might also like: Every Golden Globes Best Drama Winner Since 1952
1995: ‘Forrest Gump’ wins Best Picture over ‘Pulp Fiction’
Quentin Tarantino’s Pulp Fiction was a counterculture hit that impressed fervor and a number of other copycat movies within the years to comply with, and it was an apparent favourite on the Academy Awards. While the movie gained Best Original Screenplay, Pulp Fiction misplaced to Forrest Gump, a movie a few slow-witted man and his participation in a number of American historic occasions. Both movies are nonetheless cherished and referenced constantly to at the present time, however many cinephiles lament the loss of the edgier Pulp Fiction to the extra sentimental Forrest Gump.
2003: Roman Polanski wins Best Director for ‘The Pianist’
When Roman Polanski gained the Academy Award for Best Director with The Pianist, he didn’t stroll up on stage to just accept the trophy; in truth, Polanski was not within the United States in any respect, as stepping foot within the U.S. would have resulted in his arrest. Even after his responsible plea for statutory rape, Polanski’s friends within the filmmaking neighborhood supported him on the time. In the wake of Time’s Up and Me Too, nevertheless, Polanski’s work and accolades have been reexamined. The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences included Polanski of their expulsion of Bill Cosby from its membership.
2017: Casey Affleck wins Best Actor for ‘Manchester by the Sea’
Actress Brie Larson handed Casey Affleck his Academy Award for Best Actor, however many noticed that she didn’t applaud for his win. This was seen as Larson, who portrayed a sexual assault sufferer in Room, silently protesting Affleck, who was accused of sexual harassment on the set of his movie I’m Still Here. In the wake of the rising variety of Me Too and Time’s Up-related scandals, Affleck dropped out of presenting within the following yr’s Oscar ceremony.
1999: ‘Shakespeare in Love’ wins Best Picture over ‘Saving Private Ryan’
Steven Spielberg’s warfare drama Saving Private Ryan is taken into account by critics and viewers to be not solely among the best warfare movies of all time however one of many best movies interval. Imagine their shock when interval romantic-comedy-drama Shakespeare in Love pulled an upset win for probably the most prestigious movie prize. The win is attributed to producer Harvey Weinstein’s aggressive campaign for the film, which has set the tone for Oscar campaigning since then. But the win did not age properly because of the accusations of rape and sexual harassment towards Weinstein that garnered a lot consideration in 2017.
2005: ‘Crash’ wins Best Picture over ‘Brokeback Mountain’
The same-sex love story Brokeback Mountain, which starred Jake Gyllenhaal and the late Heath Ledger, had each crucial and monetary success and have become an early favourite to win the Best Picture award. To the shock of many, the ensemble movie Crash pulled an upset win, prompting discussion for years afterward, notably about whether or not the Academy was reluctant to award a movie that featured homosexual protagonists. The win is usually remembered as one of many Academy’s “biggest mistakes,” with the movie’s depiction of race relations thought-about now greater than ever to be outdated and based mostly on stereotypes. The movie’s director Paul Haggis even considers the movie to be unworthy of the honour.
You might also like: The 50 Biggest Box Office Flops of All Time